6 min read

Fewer Earnings Calls Could Make Guidance Your Loudest Signal

AI Summary

Picture your CFO stopping by your desk with one question. If we reported twice a year, what would investors lose? You have about thirty seconds, and "it depends" won't land well.

Picture your CFO stopping by your desk with one question. If we reported twice a year, what would investors lose? You have about thirty seconds, and "it depends" won't land well.

The SEC formally proposed an optional semiannual reporting framework on May 5, 2026. The comment period closed on July 6, and at the time of writing the SEC still lists it as a proposed rule. Nobody can say yet how it ends. That uncertainty is the reason to work out your answer now, while there is time to think it through.

IR teams that wait for a final rule will be writing their approach in a hurry. Teams that sketch two versions of their calendar today will have room to make good choices.

The proposal is optional, and that is the tricky part

Under the proposal, companies that file Form 10-Qs today could elect to file one Form 10-S covering the first six months of their fiscal year in place of three quarterly reports. The annual Form 10-K would remain. Companies would make the election each year by checking a box on the 10-K, and the choice would hold for the full year. Investors could then compare companies on different rhythms side by side.

Here is the part IROs would sit with. If your company moves to semiannual reporting while peers continue filing quarterly, investors may question the difference in disclosure frequency. If you maintain quarterly reporting, you may preserve a level of financial visibility that investors have come to expect. Either decision will need to account for shareholder expectations, peer practices and the resources required to maintain the reporting process.

The decision involves a trade-off between reporting efficiency and the frequency of structured financial disclosure.

Investment professionals have already weighed in

A CFA Institute survey of about 2,500 of its members, who work as analysts and portfolio managers, found that 62% of respondents opposed replacing quarterly reporting with semiannual reporting. Nearly 85% also said they were concerned about comparability between companies, since reporting frequency and format would vary. While 82% supported allowing companies to continue reporting quarterly voluntarily, only 32% expected companies to do so if quarterly reporting became optional.

Two caveats apply. It was a membership survey fielded in January 2026, before the SEC made its proposal, and CFA Institute later urged the SEC to defer the proposal.

Still, it shows where many of the people who read your disclosures stand. Different audiences will ask different questions. Institutions will want to know how you plan to keep them current between reports, and retail holders may ask why they are seeing less.

Guidance carries more weight if updates slow down

Under the proposal, the gap between mandatory filings would grow from about three months to about six. Companies could keep issuing quarterly earnings releases and hosting calls, and Sidley notes that established public companies are likely to keep releasing quarterly results. If a company cuts back both its mandatory filings and its voluntary quarterly updates, investors could face longer stretches without fresh financial information. They will fill that gap with whatever they can find. Guidance and conference remarks carry more weight when there is less hard data to anchor on.

So what does the playbook look like? Start by deciding how you will talk about guidance and how often you will update it. Then decide how you will explain a change before anyone asks.

Consider a calendar-year company that issues full-year revenue guidance in February. By May, a supply issue has changed its outlook. These dates are illustrative. Under a quarterly model, the May update gives the company a scheduled moment to address the change. If it moved to semiannual filings and dropped the quarterly release, finance and legal, along with IR, would need to assess whether the development triggers a disclosure obligation or warrants a voluntary update. That assessment needs a documented process before the first time it happens. Under the proposal, that company's Form 10-S would cover January through June, with the filing due in August.

Build a disclosure calendar that works either way

The most practical step is to map your year both ways. Build two calendars, one with quarterly SEC filings and another with semiannual filings. On each, map earnings releases, calls, investor conferences, board meetings and recurring disclosure obligations. According to NIRI, companies could still make voluntary quarterly disclosures and host quarterly earnings calls.

Then look at the second calendar and ask where the long stretches are. Longer periods without public financial updates could leave investors questioning whether the company's outlook has changed, particularly when market conditions or business performance shift between reporting dates.

Before deciding which communications to retain, consider what financial information investors currently receive each quarter, what they would lose under a semiannual schedule, and how frequently they expect updates on key business drivers. Look at how your closest peers report, too.

If a company adopts semiannual reporting, it should evaluate which voluntary communications are worth retaining. These could include scheduled business updates, earnings calls or investor presentations, depending on shareholder expectations and disclosure considerations. Investor meetings can help maintain dialogue, but they should not be treated as a substitute for public financial disclosure.

How could semiannual reporting affect Reg FD considerations?

The proposed reporting framework would not eliminate existing Reg FD or Form 8-K obligations. But companies that reduce scheduled public updates may need to review how they manage investor conversations between reporting periods. The concern is whether material information could be shared selectively when fewer public financial updates are available.

If your CEO shares material nonpublic information about a shift in demand with an investor in a private meeting, that could trigger Reg FD obligations. An intentional selective disclosure requires public disclosure at the same time, and an unintentional one requires prompt public disclosure afterward. You need a clear rule for what can be said in a one-on-one and what has to go out to everyone at once.

Work with legal to establish clear disclosure protocols and train executives on material nonpublic information. Then define when an issue needs to be escalated before an investor conversation.

What to watch between now and a final rule

Watch the final text first, since it sets the ground rules. Then check the effective date, transition requirements and how companies would make their annual reporting election. Each one changes how fast you need to move.

NIRI has pulled together resources on the proposal on its advocacy pages, and law firm updates deserve a read as they land. If your counsel hasn't briefed your CFO yet, offer to arrange it. You will want finance and legal aligned with IR before any change goes to the board.

The takeaway for IR teams

We think a real risk is waiting for a final rule before you plan. Even if your company stays quarterly, some investors may ask which model you plan to follow and why. Having a clear answer, grounded in what your shareholders want, makes you look prepared.

If you do move to semiannual reporting, treat guidance as your most visible communication. Keep guidance clear and build a process for reviewing changes in outlook, so you can communicate updates when appropriate. Explain every change in plain language, and make sure your website and your presentation tell the same story as your talking points.

The question for IR teams is bigger than how often their company files financial reports. It's how much information investors need to assess performance, evaluate management's outlook and make informed decisions.

The SEC's proposal gives companies a reason to examine that question now. Start with your shareholders' expectations, look at how your peers communicate, and assess what would change under a semiannual schedule. Whatever reporting cadence your company ultimately chooses, the goal should be a disclosure approach that supports consistent, credible investor communication.

If you want to see how far your internal forecast and the Street’s numbers sit apart today, take a look at how Q4’s consensus management tracks it.

Explore More IR Insights
5 min read

Fewer Earnings Calls Could Make Guidance Your Loudest Signal

Picture your CFO stopping by your desk with one question. If we reported twice a year, what would investors lose? You...
5 min read

What are ChatGPT and Claude Telling Investors About Your Company?

Picture a portfolio manager with a call on her calendar at 2 p.m. Your CEO is on the other end. At 1:45 she opens an AI...
5 min read

Does an Earnings Call Affect Stock Price?

The short answer Yes. An earnings call can move a stock, and often it does so independently of the numbers. Academic...
5 min read

Event Recap: Modern Consensus Management at CIRI Senior IRO Leadership Day

Ask any IRO about consensus and you'll hear the same frustration. A group of analysts builds forecasts on your...

MORE FROM Q4 INC

Looking for where to go from here?

See all the latest research, guides, and on-demand webinars from Q4 Inc, the leading provider of AI-driven IR Ops software